Quantcast

Business Cards Critique

jferguson757's picture

So I was wondering what some of the criticism you guys would have for these business cards. I'm not a professional, but would love to get to that point.

Thanks!

oh yeah, the belly dance card is front and back. and for some reason the picture in the post is showing up a little pixelated. hmmm... ooh... and looking at the belly dance ones, the colors don't match up...that'll have to change. and the white boarder won't be there.

1j

card 5 front

card 5 backd

natobasso's picture

Not bad, but a few things to

Not bad, but a few things to consider:

1. Too many planes. I thought they were fish at first! :)

2. Belly dancer should take up more of the card, say 2/3 under the title. Make title stand out better (more contrast).

3. Too many different fonts and it looks like you squished some to make them fit. Don't mess with fonts until you know what you are doing. Many years were spent making fonts kern correctly; don't mess with it.

----
Powerpoint is not a design application
My latest web design work

jferguson757's picture

excellent! thanks!

excellent! thanks!

gwells's picture

what's with all of the letterspacing?

makes it difficult to read and doesn't add anything to the design or seem to fit any concept.

not quite sure why you chose the odd typeface on the belly dancer card. and you have the opposite problem there, where the tracking is so tight that it's difficult to read.

3dogmama's picture

Agree. Work on typeface

Agree. Work on typeface issues. Your graphics are stunning--flying fish and all--but the text is hurting.

REALLY like your belly dancer one--the bubbles were a great addition; no changes on the front. However, I'm not crazy about the identical image and text reading backwards in the screened background on the back/info side of the card. Were you going for a "looking through a drinking glass" feel? Maybe think of dropping the full image of the woman and her backwards name, and replacing with a close-up of her navel. And definitely consider adding some more of those awesome bubbles here!

ttfn!
3dogmama

KMac's picture

1. I'm not a big fan of the

1. I'm not a big fan of the out-of-focus typeface here.

2. Your belly dancer looks like her arms are cut off. Also, the pose looks awkward (body in a straight-board position). It would look sexier - which is what belly dancing is all about - if her head and back were arched, if you want to keep this position. Otherwise, I think it's a great idea to do a close up of her navel, as 3dogmama suggested.

The font is too distracting on this business card as well. I know you're trying to be creative, but remember, simplicity can be very effective.

Katie McDonald

High Quality Business Card Designs

jferguson757's picture

T Y POg R AP hY!!!

thank you guys! typography is definitely my downfall. anyone know of some good tutorials or resources to help me iron out some of the kinks? as for the navel...very cool idea! i think i actually do have a close up of her mid-section somewhere.

Mintsauce's picture

Check this out

spotteddick's picture

Belly Buttons Rock!

I like the navel closeup concept, but leave the bubbles out. They are not doing anything for your illustration.

jferguson757's picture

do you mean leave the

do you mean leave the bubbles out in the mid-section pic or leave them out all toghether?

spotteddick's picture

Tiny Bubbles

For me the bubbles are overpowering. I'm not quite sure the significance they bring to the image. Try developing a more mysterious and seductive angle. Play with lighting and shadows to enhance the illusion of this ancient dance form.

mara06's picture

The bubbles are a weird

The bubbles are a weird retro cross between Carmen Miranda and Esther Williams (look 'em up). Doesn't say belly dancing to me at all. The position of the dancer's head looks strained, not at all conveying the controlled abandonment that belly dancing is.

You might want to post this request for critiques in the Critique section of this site. I'm sure there are some designers here who would comment constructively, but won't see your Forum post.

Mara

jferguson757's picture

good idea!

thanks for the idea! i do have another version of this picture that is completely different from the bubbles..i'll have to post it too. or maybe i should just change to a different picture with a different pose all together?

natobasso's picture

The pose could be much

The pose could be much better if the framing was better. Move the dancer up so she takes up 2/3 of the card, and put the bubbles under her rather than over her; maybe they will make her look like she's floating effortlessly rather than bending over backwards in pain as she is now. :)

I like the look of this, so hopefully it won't go away.

----
Powerpoint is not a design application
flikWORLD Design

jferguson757's picture

another version

here's another version that doesn't utilize the bubbles. i don't have many different poses, but there are a couple more that i'll post when i get the time.
and for some reason the picture comes out all funky here in the post. anyone know why it's so pixelated?

Morgan Business Card 1

natobasso's picture

Don't really like this one.

Don't really like this one. It looks very victorian and stuffy (conservative) compared to your first version. Not to mention it looks like you have a legless dancer floatinig in a magic show there... :)

I'd stick with your earlier version, just make the dancer the focus.

----
Powerpoint is not a design application
flikWORLD Design

mbennett2's picture

I think you should submit

I think you should submit this as a separate critique for both cards, as you will get more defined responses that way. I will wait for that to comment...

User login

Partner With Us













Latest critique

Fin-Tek