Quantcast

Creativebits.org

an All Creative World site
RohanJM's picture
103 pencils

Dental Logo

I'd like an opinion on which one is better and if time permits a reason as well.

Thanks
Rohan

Dental Logo

Commenting on this Image is closed.

MacRankin's picture
10 pencils

I think you should lose the top one. I don't like the colour, and it doesn't remind me of smiles. If anything, it kind of reminds me of someone preparing to sit on something.

The bottom one is a little bit more interesting, but aqain it's not all that convincing. I see this little plane trailing off into the distance, and instead of it reading beyond smiles it now almost looks like beyond miles.

I would have thought that the message of 'beyond smiles' conjours up - to me anyhow, of people laughing and being pleased with themselves. Perhaps you could work that image into the background while still using the same colours.

Or, how about losing that airplane-like smile and slapping a lipstick laden kiss around, or through the beyond word?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

We Brits do things differently, but we still get shot at!

mokenke's picture
315 pencils

I would try the top one on white instead of it being in a box. It looks to rigid and that contrasts with a curved, stylized smile. Rigid, in this case, in my mind, does not go well with dentist. I want something more friendly than that. I hate dentists.

mokenke

Apfhex's picture
325 pencils

The blue box doesn't need to be part of a logo. If that was a business card or something, might look nice.

I like the top design a lot more but maybe you could make the curve look a tiiiiny bit more like a smile (but don't get too literal).

Also, it looks like "smiles" isn't quite centered (at least optically) below "beyond".

pokie's picture
1198 pencils

I'm the odd one out, it looks like.

I actually like the bottom one better-- hands down.

It's just all around a better composition. It also gets the point across but not too much. The "swoosh" thing is a bit overused these days though...

dpc's picture
359 pencils

the second one looks like a smile... while the 1st does not.

http://www.davidpcrawford.com - http://www.vomit76.com

Graphic, Web and Logo Designer from Pittsburgh, PA http://www.davidpcrawford.com

natobasso's picture
3954 pencils

Def second one. No blue box. Think about applying this logo from the size of a favicon (see creative bits' favicon in your browser? Small!) up to a billboard. If the logo works across all sizes then it's good, in my opinion.

----
Client: "can you guys make it more like a power-point presentation, you know, with the sliding text stuff and all?" (http://clientcopia.com/quotes.php?id=7)

Creativebits is a blog about creativity, design and Macs. We also have a critique section where you can post your work to get opinions and a forum to discuss any design related topics.

Recommend us on Google

Latest critique

  • Butterfingers ad campaign
  • Critique for my logo

Marketplace