Creativebits.org

an All Creative World site
shii's picture
26 pencils

Illustration for Science 2

I took Creative NRG's advice about the text.

Commenting on this Image is closed.

mara06's picture
2548 pencils

Now if you'll just take mine about space on the bottom right, under the logo...

Mara

plugz's picture
1244 pencils

And for some reason that image isn't working there in the top left.

It's gone too small now I think.
What about larger and at a tint?

shii's picture
26 pencils

haha...actually on the illustrator it is not at the edge. just that when i save it as a jpeg it doesn't show that extra space :)

pokie's picture
1198 pencils

What are the rest of us, chopped liver? I think you should do without the image still. Change it, something. Why is that little logo at the bottom on the edge? It's going to get chopped off.

shii's picture
26 pencils

as i said, it isn't at the edge, just the way it is saved in jpeg. in the illustrator it is further away.

you know, i'm getting so much negatives about this new look. i guess i'd better stick to the old plain one. i personally like that better too. thanks guys.

Creative_NRG's picture
483 pencils

Pokie,

From what I see 'seraphim', 'Mara06' and myself were the only ones to give specific feedback on his last design concept.

If you want homage try providing more than... "Good. I totally agree with the other posters. It will also make it more mysterious."

I will give you one thing... you're the master of the 1-line critique. ;P

pokie's picture
1198 pencils

Erm, my chopped liver thing was a joke.

The rudeness was a nice touch though, thank you.

Creative_NRG's picture
483 pencils

dupe

Ivan's picture

I like the top corner illustration. Type is too aligned too balanced. Make it more dynamic somehow.

Chez A's picture
89 pencils

The text looks great but unfortunately I find your illustration on top unnecessary (not that I don't like it). I would suggest incorporating your illustration along with the text but be sure to keep it simple ... see how you could play around with the letter "i"s on the words "proving" and "possibilities" ...

Just a side note, that logo at the bottom reminds me so much of the Montreal Canadians (Habs) logo ...

shii's picture
26 pencils

i know, many members critiqued about that. but that is not my work; it is their logo *shrugs*

for more information/critiques, i have included the link to the original post: http://creativebits.org/brochure_cover_for_college_of_science_and_engineering

tlarson2k's picture
66 pencils

The first thing I thought after looking at the thumbnail and reading the headline "disproving impossibilities", is that there is no punch line. Unless the image on the top left is proving or disproving something (and I'm the first to say I'm not a science or engineering major so maybe it is?), then I don't really get a pay off from the visual on the top left.

Maybe you can do some research with the help of your client and see if there is something that both proves and disproves something and use that as a clever visual. You may not reach all potential targets (aka laymen), but those that do get it probably are your target market anyway.

Granted, this doesn't have to be a "see and say" ad, but I was hoping for a clever image to go with the clever wordplay. Since the text works on it's own, I'd argue that this work can do without the molecular graphic.

plugz's picture
1244 pencils

Needs more rabbit and top hat.

shii's picture
26 pencils

ah the image. yes, they were thinking of using m.c. escher's work for a more 'impossible' image.

Creativebits is a blog about creativity, design and Macs. We also have a critique section where you can post your work to get opinions and a forum to discuss any design related topics.

Recommend us on Google

Latest critique

Do you need a great new logo?

If you need a logo for your company or product you can get it done with us.
In our logo store you can pick from over 28,000 pre-made logos that will be customized to your name for free or you can post a contest for us for just $250 and our designers from all over the world will submit dozens of logo design suggestions to your specific needs.

Marketplace