Internet service via satellite
Submitted by 3dogmama on Wed, 2008-04-09 23:25.
We are moving soon to a remote area that does not have DSL or cable...only dial-up (shudder). I have been looking into connecting through satellite, researching companies, reading articles, etc., but I want to know if anyone here has had any dealings with satellite connectivity?
My studio is in town, and I
My studio is in town, and I have cable there, but we live in the country, where our only options are dial-up or satellite.
We recently switched to HiughesNet. I installed an old Mac Airport Extreme so we could go wireless. That part is working fine. The satellite connection is usually smoother than the old dial-up, but I have to say I'm very disappointed in the download speeds. Also, the guys who did the installation took like four days to finish it, even though they were supposedly very experienced. They kept bringing (or were given) the wrong equipment and didn't seem to be getting very good support from "HughesNet Central."
There are several online forums out there where this issue is discussed, along with some potential workarounds. Have you checked into those? Which companies serve your region? HughesNet apparently has a pretty lousy reputation. Maybe others are better. Or maybe local conditions create problems in some areas but not others, so HughesNet (if they serve your area) might be wonderful for you. Any new neighbors you could call on to introduce yourself and get some practical advice about this and other things?
Good luck with your move. "Remote" has many advantages. Unfortunately, access to the most advanced technology usually isn't among them.
Mara
There are a couple of
There are a couple of providers for the area, one of them being a distributor for HughesNet, and I skimmed a few of the forums out there but didn't really land on a solution.
I'm curious to know your speeds, Mara, as the one I'm leaning towards has an upload speed of 200 kbps and a download of 1.0 Mbps.
ciao
3dogmama
I don'r know how to measure
I don't know how to measure my speeds exactly. I go only by how long downloads take, which seems like forever. I recently saw something flash before my eyes while I was updating some software -- 8kps. Our dialup was 15kps, I think. Does that tell you anything? If you can tell me where to find the info you asked for, I'll go check.
Mara
speed testing
Your dial-up sounds about right, and for determining speed, I've used the following tests:
http://www.bplspeedtest.com/
and
http://speedtest.net/
Thanks so much for this, Mara.
3dogmama
I'll do that test this
I'll do that test this evening when I get home -- might be sooner than this evening, actually. I want to take advantage of this nice sunny day to make some more progress on my vegetable garden.
Mara
I hear you. It's been such a
I hear you. It's been such a long winter. I'm hoping to escape a little earlier this afternoon into the gardens as well to take advantage of the day. My spring bulbs and hostas are beginning to appear and I have a yard to clean up.
Again, thanks for the help, Mara.
ciao
3dogmama
Those two sites gave VERY
Those two sites gave VERY different results, 256Kb and 850Kb respectively. Which one is more accurate, I wonder?
----
Powerpoint is not a design application
I saw that and have no idea
I saw that and have no idea which is which either. They differed on my service by approximately 1/3. I may have to try even another test site and apply the best two out of three theory.
ciao
3dogmama
I'm more inclined to take
I'm more inclined to take the lower number. :\
----
Powerpoint is not a design application
It's still faster than what
It's still faster than what will be available to where we're moving.
Crap.
Oh well, at least it will give me time to walk the dogs while I wait for a file to upload.
ciao
3dogmama
If I am not mistaken, I
If I am not mistaken, I believe the Dish Network offers high speed satellite internet as well. Haven't used it and don't know anyone who has, just throwing that out as something to look into...
Thanks.
I'll check into the Dish too to see if they service that area. Good ole Ma Bell, our current DSL and satellite provider, doesn't...only dial-up.
ciao
3dogmama
http://www.auditmypc.com/internet-speed-test.asp
This one gave me 2.6 Mbps for my downloading and 709 kbps for my up. As per the above links, bpl gave me 1.864 as a down and 774 as an up; speedtest gave me 2.548 as a down and 52 (!?) as an up. If going by the 2 out of 3 rule, I think the best bet would be this new link...unless anyone has a suggestion.
ciao
3dogmama
For what it's worth...
...I ran both tests and got numbers in the same ballpark each time for download and upload speed:
www.bplspeedtest.com/
Download Speed 751 kbps
Upload Speed 159 kbps
http://speedtest.net/
799/186
The http://www.auditmypc.com/internet-speed-test.asp site gave me 847.5 for download speed, then crapped out on me.
What does it all mean? :-)
I love my cable connection at work. Oh and BTW, neither my husband nor I have been able to get our e-mail to download at home. We're lost in some endless loop of rejected passwords. He's Vista, I'm Leopard. Nice t'meetcha.
Mara
Thanks for running the
Thanks for running the tests, Mara. Your speeds sound about the same as what we're getting into.
For curiousity's sake, you should try these tests on your cable hook-up to see the difference between the two. Then again maybe not...it might drive you to drink.
Sorry that I can't offer any advice on the email issue. Haven't ran into that type of headache yet.
ciao
3dogmama
You can be certain I'll run
You can be certain I'll run those tests at work, if only so I can feel smug about not being a hausfrau -- although, I have to tell you, I have wicked fantasies about that. Ah, but such is the curse of the modern age that my fantasy involves download speeds instead of, hmmm, the milkman. Oh well :-)
Here's hoping you don't run into e-mail trouble. Our best friends, who got HughesNet at their house a few months before we did, also went through a period when their e-mail got totally screwed up. It might be a rite of passage with HughesNet, I dunno. How do these guys get away with it? Arrrggh.
Mara
Just for grins
Here's what I've got at work, per the three different test sites:
Download 14.2 Mbps/Upload 2267 kbps
Download 22278 kbps/Upload 2301kbps
Download 26.75 Mbps/Upload 1967 Kbps
And my husband wonders why I work late so often!
Mara
I have had internet through
I have had internet through satellite before through Starband and I do not recommend this service to anyone. You can not go on the internet if there is a thunder storm or clouds in the way of the satellite I warn you do not get it.
Thanks, but unfortunately
Thanks, but unfortunately where we're moving to does not offer up a whole lot of choices. A friend, who already resides in the area, will be running another set of tests this weekend with a mobile service he uses. Hopefully his solution will work and save the initial 1G initial outlay of cashola for the satellite system and the accompanying headaches.
"Without deviation from the norm, progress is not possible."
— Frank Zappa