Magazine Ad
This is for Graphic Design class. I was to create a one page ad for Hampton Hotels. The ad is to atract families who want to go on vacation together.
Hotels by the beach..
Thanks for your comments..
User login
Navigation
Latest critique
Active forum topics
looks very professional for student work.
One minor suggestion: don't hyphenate the client's name in the body text.
Did you design the logo? Nice job.
The logo was the only thing
The logo was the only thing given to me by the professor.. Yeah I noticed the Hypenation mistake after I mounted it and turned it in..
Thanks..
Real nice work again Juan
As Gary said, don't hyphenate the client name.
I love the layout and general feel of the ad.
Looks great - nice one!
__
Goo
My thoughts..
The H in Hampton in the logo looks just terrible.. I guess it's a default style found in Photoshop or something.. Perhaps have a check at the text and fix it so words like Hampton Hotels get on it's own row and so on..
Othervise It looks good..
nice
very nice, looks very professional like right out of a magazine.. the only thing that stood out to me a little like tigerstorm above is the H.. it would look natural if i was flipping through the pages but after looking at it for 3 secs i would say just give it a very very thin stroke/outline, and maybe the slightest drop shadow, but just make it stick out (literally) a little more. and if im not getting picky enough, maybe fade the gradient that fills it just a little bit or give it like 80-90% opacity and see how that looks..
very nice ill have to look at this when i make a simple magazine ad
It sucks
I am a very hard critiquer but man the distance between the H and the N and H and H is different! "Every great hotel deserves a family" You should never compliment your self. The boy's clothes do not fit the poster. Instead of three thumbnails put four. Paragraph should not be there. Style on H sucks. I recomend shifting the H to the beggining of the logo so it would be
"H&H Hampton Hotels"
Hampton Hotels in a smaller font.
Curning stinks too.
How much do I have to tell people.
NEVER PUT A SHADOW ON A LOGO. IT ONLY CAUSES PROBLEMS.
You can replace the H&H with:
H
Talk about 'Sucking'
I appreciate an eye for detail but did you have to be such an arrogant jerk? If you're going write an asshole critique to a student at least learn how to spell 'KERNING'. That's a fundamental design principle and spelling it 'Curning' makes you look like a complete moron.
And here are some other things to consider:
critiquer is not a word
your self should be spelled "yourself"
"How much do I have to tell people." [needs a question mark, not a period.]
recomend should be spelled "recommend"
Where is the H&H you keep referring to?
Don't tell someone his work sucks when it's better than what's on your website.
"You should never compliment your self."
Please consider taking your own advice and stop complimenting yourself.
That aside, I think you owe this fine young designer an apology for your hostile comments.
Your choice of words may be more a matter of not understanding English than of any aggressive intention. If so, I suggest that you refrain from offering sensitive criticism of other people's work until you are able to communicate adequately in their language.
Mara
"critiquer" is not a word
There's also an etiquette for conversation or conveying opinions to others, and your post has none of it.
Edit: On the other hand, your post made me curious to see your website. I have to admit, it was very humorous in all aspects (content and programming).
Waleed
www.waleedsgallery.biz
Lovely
A very polished job! Congratulations.
I won't mention the hyphenation issue, because you already know about that. You do need to nudge the decorative "H" to the right, so it's centered between the Hilton and Hotel.
Was the photo your choice? It's charming, and suits the theme, but the hotel in the background doesn't look very appealing, does it? It seems rather more like something under construction. You might want to consider layering in a better shot of the place, or maybe enhancing the Black plate in that area, to give it just a little more definition without ruining the "foggy distance" idea.
Again, very nice work! Be sure to show us more as you continue your education.
Mara
My age
I am 12. Give me a break about kurning
You're 12???
I'm sorry, unless you have at least a little bit of experience and an education beyond the 8th grade, you do not have the right to critique someone else's work, especially in the hostile manner that you chose. And it's KERNING, geez—it was spelled out for you earlier and you still cannot remember how to spell it? MAJOR aspect of design—know your typography (and the labels—tail, arm, bar, ascender, descender, spine, cap height, etc.) and other very important aspects of design, like leading & kerning, etc.
My recommendation? Get some pubic hair and experience before you insult others on their designing techniques, especially when you obviously are not a designer and consider yourself one just because you know how to write HTML and use Photoshop. There's more to design than just knowing the applications.
As far as the magazine ad goes—I think it looks very professional and I like the idea of the tagline, I think it fits except for the fact that you really can't see the hotel. If you're going to use the tagline "Every great hotel deserves a great family" then make the hotel a little more prominent than it is (deep in the background). Otherwise, I love it! It's appropriate and it's a really nice magazine ad. I hope your professor likes it, too.
Good luck!
Mara
Mara
Hello jcxm360
I would change the big image. The people are okey, but the background looks foggy (not like neverending beach), the building (hotel) looks under construction. The little images are okey. The typo and the used font looks very good. The effected H is a kitsch in my eyes. The drop#ed shadow behind the "Hampton Hotels is enough. I wouldn't use this H.
Professional designers are making little mistakes, too. Nobody perfect...
Good Luck!
Make the headline more
Make the headline more prominent and you're there! ;)
There's a hierarchy of information that needs to be followed. What's the most important message about your ad that the client wants to get across? That should be the headline, and that should be the first thing your eye sees.
Well done.
Nathaniel
Bass. Graphic Design. Junior IT.