Just a card I whipped up. Wondering what people wold think if they came in a picked up a card. The card would be made in a transparent plastic. Tell me what you think.
I think the typeface you have chosen does not reflect design, and as far as your logo goes, how well would it be reproduced in black and white, and does it follow simple logo rules? — Simplistic, memorable, flat colour if possible, etc etc.
The pear looks like it is rotten and has mould or something growing on it.
Try use more white space, everything is looking abit cluttered, how big is your type on your card? Could possibly also reduce the size.
You are brave posting this on a design community forum, perhaps you could make good business already with the logo etc you have now, but as "designers" its our nature to bitch about the appearance of peoples work!
Umm....nope. Sorry. I dont like it. If you print this on transparent plastic, you would be wasting your money.
A) I dont like the layout....or colors. Too blah.
B) the pear is obnoxiously distracting....gives the impression that you sell fruit.
C) I googled "pear" and found that exact "pear image" on a website. It doesn't belong to you. Thats called stealing my friend.
D) If this firm is serious about getting business, it needs a reputable logo and business card. Not just something you "WHIPPED" up.
Well, I am in a deisgn class in high school and we made this the first week. So we didn't use our own pictures because it was the first week, but I like the way the pear looked. I made it a vector and went on from there.
In the design world, when you ask for a critique its absolutely necessary to justify and explain why your work was designed the way it is. Justify the fonts, colors, images and layout. In addition, if you would have mentioned that you are a 1 week old design student in your initial posting, I thing most people here wouldn't have been as harsh as they were. You made yourself seem like an established design professional douche-bag, who just "whipped up" a bad business card. If your serious about your design, re-work your business card and re-post it. Mention that you are a student, and you will see that the people here can actually be encouraging and quite helpful.
noooope. There is nothing memorable about this. Why would you just base your entire branding of yourself based on "i liked the way the pear looked". Thats weak and of course it shows. There is a bad disconnect between the way you treated the image of the pear (a VERY apparent livetrace) and the font choice. The contact font is too big and needs to be more legible- it's too faint in areas and if you were going to print this on transparent plastic- I feel bad for anyone that would have to read it.
The layout is very 'blah'. sure you COULD have your firm name way bigger then everything and center aligned at the top of the card- but what is creative about that? Hell even those not aiming towards design will center align the most important information in a document. If your design looks like a solution that a non-designer would create- then you need to stretch yourself more creatively.
you came to this site understanding that we are not a bunch of high school kids trying to critique each other. we are a compilation of professionals and students looking to understand more about our own design concepts and it's execution. I take everything I see here and place in the context of the REAL WORLD. not A CLASSROOM. just because you got an A on a high school project, does not overshadow the fact that this is a mediocre design. If you are satisfied with the criteria set by a CLASS, then that's fine- but don't fool yourself into thinking that thats the same criteria of the real world. Your comment is arrogant and insulting.
They were VERY strict. Late projects were an automatic fail. They wanted to simulate the real world as much as possible. This stuff you see in this critique section is NOTHING compared to what they had us go through.
The project in question was using Rubylith for a piece we had to do. Rubylith is basically a plastic sheet with a thin red coating on it. The idea is to cut the thinner than paper red coating on it without cutting the plastic underneath, and the edges of the cuts had to be clean, no overlapping cuts. Needless to say, one mark was deducted for every "miscut" and my teacher, *magnifying glass* in hand, really went to work on me that day. For my first semester, that was a little bit of a shock but oh well, you live and you learn. 4 sheets and 27 or so fresh exacto blades later I got a passing grade.
I was a pre-press boy all the way through my uni days. Image setters were available but I was in an old school printing firm, working with cameras and processors.
I remember having to strip-in pieces of bromide to amend one word in the sentence, having to move the rest of the text along to even up the kerning, shoot the film again, then patch it all up with red paint to make another plate.
come on, guys, give him a break. it's high school.
when working on an identity (or any design, for that matter), it's important to create a design brief. you want to put down your goals for the identity, some keywords that describe who you are and what you want people to think of when they see it. if you look around the site, you'll find some links talking about how to create a logo. they're good reading.
then when you're done with comps/drafts, you need to look at them and see if they accomplish any or all of those goals.
the problem here is that there's really no concept beyond "i like the way the pear looks." and to be successful at design, you have to be able to see a problem (you need an identity!) and find a solution (a design that says something about who you are).
graphic design isn't about "looking pretty." it's about communication. communicating a concept or idea. "pretty" without communication is a failure.
Creativebits is a blog about creativity, design and Macs. We also have a critique section where you can post your work to get opinions and a forum to discuss any design related topics.
I hate all.
And the pear is phallic.
i hope this is a joke.
"Just a card I whipped up..." Not really the best way to start a project.
What the flip is the pear about?
nil point.
living on dreams and custard creams.
Hi,
I think the typeface you have chosen does not reflect design, and as far as your logo goes, how well would it be reproduced in black and white, and does it follow simple logo rules? — Simplistic, memorable, flat colour if possible, etc etc.
The pear looks like it is rotten and has mould or something growing on it.
Try use more white space, everything is looking abit cluttered, how big is your type on your card? Could possibly also reduce the size.
You are brave posting this on a design community forum, perhaps you could make good business already with the logo etc you have now, but as "designers" its our nature to bitch about the appearance of peoples work!
Good luck though!
Ricky Sam
www.rickysam.com
Umm....nope. Sorry. I dont like it. If you print this on transparent plastic, you would be wasting your money.
A) I dont like the layout....or colors. Too blah.
B) the pear is obnoxiously distracting....gives the impression that you sell fruit.
C) I googled "pear" and found that exact "pear image" on a website. It doesn't belong to you. Thats called stealing my friend.
D) If this firm is serious about getting business, it needs a reputable logo and business card. Not just something you "WHIPPED" up.
I would start over.
Well, I am in a deisgn class in high school and we made this the first week. So we didn't use our own pictures because it was the first week, but I like the way the pear looked. I made it a vector and went on from there.
Landon...
In the design world, when you ask for a critique its absolutely necessary to justify and explain why your work was designed the way it is. Justify the fonts, colors, images and layout. In addition, if you would have mentioned that you are a 1 week old design student in your initial posting, I thing most people here wouldn't have been as harsh as they were. You made yourself seem like an established design professional douche-bag, who just "whipped up" a bad business card. If your serious about your design, re-work your business card and re-post it. Mention that you are a student, and you will see that the people here can actually be encouraging and quite helpful.
With that said, my initial comments still stand.
I don't even know where to start....
Leaky Penny
Check out what I've been up to lately!
http://petersonjoseph.com
I'm going to print it out and eat it.
-Unknown Artist
Illustrator livetrace for the win! What a way to start your design firm!
http://jackmancer.com/
http://twitter.com/jackmancer
noooope. There is nothing memorable about this. Why would you just base your entire branding of yourself based on "i liked the way the pear looked". Thats weak and of course it shows. There is a bad disconnect between the way you treated the image of the pear (a VERY apparent livetrace) and the font choice. The contact font is too big and needs to be more legible- it's too faint in areas and if you were going to print this on transparent plastic- I feel bad for anyone that would have to read it.
The layout is very 'blah'. sure you COULD have your firm name way bigger then everything and center aligned at the top of the card- but what is creative about that? Hell even those not aiming towards design will center align the most important information in a document. If your design looks like a solution that a non-designer would create- then you need to stretch yourself more creatively.
Well just to let you know I got an A so I'm happy.
I'm interested in your teachers portfolio then ;-)
http://jackmancer.com/
http://twitter.com/jackmancer
you came to this site understanding that we are not a bunch of high school kids trying to critique each other. we are a compilation of professionals and students looking to understand more about our own design concepts and it's execution. I take everything I see here and place in the context of the REAL WORLD. not A CLASSROOM. just because you got an A on a high school project, does not overshadow the fact that this is a mediocre design. If you are satisfied with the criteria set by a CLASS, then that's fine- but don't fool yourself into thinking that thats the same criteria of the real world. Your comment is arrogant and insulting.
True. Grades mean nothing in design class. I've gotten -35% with one teacher and 140% with another.
Leaky Penny
Check out what I've been up to lately!
http://petersonjoseph.com
I'm going to print it out and eat it.
-Unknown Artist
wow, that's just craaaazy! a -35%???!!!
They were VERY strict. Late projects were an automatic fail. They wanted to simulate the real world as much as possible. This stuff you see in this critique section is NOTHING compared to what they had us go through.
The project in question was using Rubylith for a piece we had to do. Rubylith is basically a plastic sheet with a thin red coating on it. The idea is to cut the thinner than paper red coating on it without cutting the plastic underneath, and the edges of the cuts had to be clean, no overlapping cuts. Needless to say, one mark was deducted for every "miscut" and my teacher, *magnifying glass* in hand, really went to work on me that day. For my first semester, that was a little bit of a shock but oh well, you live and you learn. 4 sheets and 27 or so fresh exacto blades later I got a passing grade.
Leaky Penny
Check out what I've been up to lately!
http://petersonjoseph.com
I'm going to print it out and eat it.
-Unknown Artist
I was a pre-press boy all the way through my uni days. Image setters were available but I was in an old school printing firm, working with cameras and processors.
I remember having to strip-in pieces of bromide to amend one word in the sentence, having to move the rest of the text along to even up the kerning, shoot the film again, then patch it all up with red paint to make another plate.
Thank god for CTP
living on dreams and custard creams.
that makes me cry. But at the same time, I wish my school pushed our class like that.
A's are for biginners, come back when you are serious. and still got A in four years..
-edit- Doh, My Englisch is so bad sometimes we got the metric system, A is high?
come on, guys, give him a break. it's high school.
when working on an identity (or any design, for that matter), it's important to create a design brief. you want to put down your goals for the identity, some keywords that describe who you are and what you want people to think of when they see it. if you look around the site, you'll find some links talking about how to create a logo. they're good reading.
then when you're done with comps/drafts, you need to look at them and see if they accomplish any or all of those goals.
the problem here is that there's really no concept beyond "i like the way the pear looks." and to be successful at design, you have to be able to see a problem (you need an identity!) and find a solution (a design that says something about who you are).
graphic design isn't about "looking pretty." it's about communication. communicating a concept or idea. "pretty" without communication is a failure.